RISC-V takes first step toward international ISO/IEC standardization

RISC‑V chases global seal of approval — hype vs. “ISO paperwork” skeptics

TLDR: RISC‑V can now submit its chip blueprint for official ISO/IEC recognition, a key step toward a global standard. Commenters are split: fans see adoption fuel, skeptics see red tape, paywall risks, and no “killer” chips yet—making this a credibility test as much as a standards milestone.

RISC‑V just scored a ticket to the big leagues: it can now submit its open chip blueprint to the ISO/IEC standards club for a global seal of approval. The org behind it, RISC‑V International, says this PAS status with ISO/IEC JTC 1 is about trust and consistency—think Wi‑Fi‑style rules so everyone’s gadgets play nice.

But the internet had thoughts. One camp cheered the “finally, grown‑up status!” angle: broader recognition could push cautious companies to adopt. Another camp rolled its eyes, calling it bureaucracy cosplay. As user jgord put it, it’s “busywork” with a marketing glow because people think “ISO = quality.” Others fretted about power and access: axblount worried this could shift control away from RISC‑V’s open community, while claudex sparked a mini‑panic over the infamous ISO paywall—would the official spec end up behind a checkout screen while the open version lags?

Then came the reality‑check brigade: darksaints asked where the killer chips are—multi‑core beasts, shiny extensions, the mythical “M5‑level” performance—arguing big players aren’t investing enough yet. Memes flew: “slap an ISO sticker on your motherboard,” “PAS = Please Approve Soon,” and “ISO DLC when?” Meanwhile, supporters countered that other open groups like W3C did this dance and survived, and that standards can cut costs and speed adoption.

So yes, it’s a milestone—but the comments section crowned a new villain: red tape. The plot twist? If RISC‑V navigates the paywall fears and keeps the spec accessible, this could turn into the growth boost fans hoped for, not the compliance drama skeptics predict.

Key Points

  • RISC-V International has been approved as an ISO/IEC JTC 1 PAS Submitter.
  • This status allows submission of the RISC-V Instruction Set Manual for ISO/IEC standard consideration.
  • JTC 1 oversees major IT standards and has recognized consortia like Khronos, W3C, and OASIS as PAS Submitters.
  • The PAS application required detailed evidence of RISC-V International’s governance, compliance, and consensus processes.
  • Consensus-based international standards improve interoperability and reduce integration costs, illustrated by the Wi‑Fi (IEEE 802.11) example.

Hottest takes

"busywork ... but maybe good marketing" — jgord
"put the RISC-V spec behind the ISO paywall" — claudex
"I really want to believe, but I don't think we'll see anything like an M5 chip anytime soon" — darksaints
Made with <3 by @siedrix and @shesho from CDMX. Powered by Forge&Hive.