November 26, 2025
Pass the gravy, pass the hot takes
Tell HN: Happy Thanksgiving
Turkey, thanks, and a spicy debate over HN’s mythical past
TLDR: A Thanksgiving post on Hacker News turned into a lovefest for longtime members and moderators, with shoutouts to the founder and memories of Aaron Swartz. Some say the quality has dipped, but most still crown HN the best spot—Lobste.rs gets a nod, hearts flood the thread.
On Hacker News, a simple “Happy Thanksgiving” exploded into a warm, slightly chaotic family reunion. Long‑timers flexed their badges—fifteen, sixteen, seventeen years—and raised a toast to dang, tomhow, and founder pg for keeping the lights on. Some broke out the nostalgia china, mourning the “mythical past,” while others reminded everyone this place still delivers real talk and real curiosity. One bittersweet thread invoked the loss of Aaron Swartz, turning the gratitude into a genuine moment of reflection. The vibe: heartfelt, a little snarky, and very online.
Then came the drama: is the vibe slipping? One veteran admitted the discourse has dipped “a little,” yet declared HN the best refuge from the wider internet’s nonsense. The science meme of the day: “the half‑life decay of this community has been slower than anywhere else,” which commenters treated like a pumpkin‑spiced take worth sipping. A tiny, dinner‑roll‑sized rivalry flared when someone nodded to Lobste.rs—good vibes, but too small for the daily feast. Meanwhile, the comments filled with <3 and thank‑yous, proving that even in a catty, brainy crowd, gratitude trends. Call it Thanksgiving canon: fewer flame wars, more feelings, and a collective promise to keep building things—and keep arguing, lovingly—another year. In short, the turkey was hot, but the takes were hotter.
Key Points
- •The author reflects on 15–17 years of participation in Hacker News.
- •Thanks are given to HN moderators dang and tomhow for consistent community stewardship.
- •The article acknowledges the community’s resilience, including during the loss of Aaron Swartz.
- •HN’s discourse quality is perceived to have slipped slightly but remains the best of its kind for the author.
- •Lobste.rs is cited as having high discourse but a smaller community and less variety than HN.