Microsoft Has Killed Widgets Six Times. Here's Why They Keep Coming Back

Microsoft keeps rebooting widgets—fans want useful info, not ads

TLDR: Microsoft has reinvented Windows widgets six times, each revival adding stricter rules for security, speed, and privacy. Commenters split: some want simple, useful tiles without ads or clutter, others insist widgets aren’t dead and just need variety—while everyone jokes that the Win+W board is hidden in plain sight.

Microsoft’s on its sixth resurrection of Windows widgets, and the crowd is split between cheering and eye-rolling. The article calls the new Widget Board “scar tissue” built from past disasters: safer JSON cards (no apps running), faster native graphics, a space-saving overlay, and opt‑in data. Translation: they learned the hard way. But the comments steal the show. One camp, led by lordkrandel, rages that generic tiles and sneaky promos miss the point—people want personal, not pushy. Another camp, like sublinear, throws shade at the headline—“clickbait!”—and argues widgets never died; they just need variety and to stay in the background. Nostalgia enters, with giuseppe yearning for the friendly Windows 98 vibes and dropping a video link. Meanwhile jauntywundrkind is quietly manifesting a simple, portable widget setup. The running meme? Groundhog Day for widgets—Microsoft builds, backlash hits, feature gets locked down tighter. People joke the Win+W panel is a secret handshake nobody knows, and there’s a brewing ad-versus-utility smackdown over Microsoft’s desire to monetize the news surface. One bright note: a rare peace treaty as dartharva applauds the article’s clean layout. Verdict: the tech is evolving, but the vibe check is the real boss.

Key Points

  • Microsoft has shipped six Windows widget implementations since 1997 to show live information without opening apps.
  • Each iteration failed for different reasons—performance, security, screen space, privacy, or engagement—prompting tighter containment.
  • Active Desktop, Vista Sidebar, Windows 7 Gadgets, and Windows 8 Start Screen illustrate the cycle of release, backlash, and redesign.
  • The current Widget Board uses Adaptive Cards (declarative JSON), native WinUI 3 rendering, and an overlay layout to address past issues.
  • Remaining challenges include developer API constraints, weak discoverability, and tension over monetizing the Discover surface.

Hottest takes

"People don't want generic 'weather' information... stock information... inbox headers" — lordkrandel
"No platform has ever 'killed' off widgets" — sublinear
"widgets are amazing & we are all just quietly hoping for a good breakaway easy travelling widget thing" — jauntywundrkind
Made with <3 by @siedrix and @shesho from CDMX. Powered by Forge&Hive.