Hard-braking events as indicators of road segment crash risk

Google says sudden stops reveal dangerous roads — insurers say 'duh'

TLDR: Google says frequent hard-braking captured by Android Auto points to crash-prone road segments, offering a faster safety warning than years of police reports. Commenters split: insurers and locals call it old news and “obvious,” while others cheer a shift toward fixing bad road design instead of blaming drivers.

Google Research just dropped a study claiming your “slam-on-the-brakes” moments—aka hard-braking events (HBEs)—can flag dangerous road segments faster than waiting years for police crash reports. Using anonymized data from Android Auto and public crash records, they found more HBEs = more crashes. Cue the comments section: insurance folks rolled their eyes. One pro chimed in that insurers have used hard braking as a top risk signal for ages, even playing a warning tone to nudge drivers. Another commenter scoffed that you don’t need fancy math to know San Jose’s I‑880/US‑101 interchange is chaos—locals literally voted it the worst.

But it wasn’t all snark. Urban planning nerds were hyped, arguing this flips the script from blaming “bad drivers” to calling out bad road design. If HBEs can spotlight cloverleaf interchanges and speed-differential danger zones, cities could triage fixes sooner. Meanwhile, the “this was obvious” crowd claimed municipalities already buy similar data from brokers, turning today’s “new” finding into yesterday’s invoice. The humor came fast: “HBEs = Help, Bad Engineering,” and “My Android Auto beep is my therapist.” Love it or roll your eyes, the vibe is clear: use those brake-slam breadcrumbs to fix the roads, not just wag fingers at drivers. Read the paper for the receipts.

Key Points

  • Google Research found a statistically significant positive correlation between hard-braking events (HBEs) and road segment crash rates.
  • HBEs are defined as forward deceleration exceeding -3 m/s², interpreted as evasive maneuvers.
  • The study combined 10 years of public crash data from Virginia and California with anonymized, aggregated HBE data from Android Auto.
  • HBEs are proposed as leading indicators for proactive safety assessment, addressing the sparsity and lag of crash-based data.
  • HBEs enable network-wide analysis using connected vehicle data, contrasting with fixed-sensor measures like time-to-collision.

Hottest takes

"Most auto insurers that do telematics consider hard braking the strongest indicator of risk" — harshaw
"But you don’t need machine learning to know that" — drewda
"It basically flips the script from individual liability to infrastructure-level risk assessment" — engelo_b
Made with <3 by @siedrix and @shesho from CDMX. Powered by Forge&Hive.