February 16, 2026
Thumb Yoga vs Macro Mania
Designing a 36-key custom keyboard layout (2021)
Tiny keyboards, huge feelings: is 36 keys genius or self‑torture
TLDR: A 36‑key keyboard layout using layer tricks sparked a split: tiny‑board loyalists vs. macro‑loving traditionalists, with a side of old‑school hoarders. The fight matters because it’s about comfort and speed—whether less hardware plus smart shortcuts beats more keys and muscle memory.
A guide to designing a 36‑key keyboard lit up the comment section like a RGB rave, and the crowd split into camps fast. The article says fewer keys can be more comfortable if you use “layers” — like secret floors you access by holding a key — and name‑checks the intense Miryoku setup with six layers and “home row mods” (letters that turn into Shift/Ctrl when held). Cue the drama.
The minimalists flexed hard. One fan bragged they type only on tiny “40%” boards and started with classics like the HHKB and the Minivan. Another pushed it further, calling 34 keys the real sweet spot and roasting “thumb yoga” layers, while plugging Callum‑style mods as a saner alternative. Meanwhile, a maximalist showed up like a boss battle: forget tiny boards, give me function keys, macros on every button, and maybe a whole second keyboard — if only their KVM (the gadget that lets you switch one keyboard between computers) could cope.
Then came the nostalgia wave: one user stockpiles old Logitech G15s like they’re prepping for the keyboard apocalypse. Others tossed shade at “algorithmic” layout designers, arguing human‑designed feels better than machine‑optimized. The memes wrote themselves: “thumb yoga,” “piano-finger Twister,” and “pocket keyboard vs macro pad hoarder.” In short: fewer keys, bigger opinions.
Key Points
- •The article argues fewer keys can improve ergonomics by keeping hands on the home row and reducing reach.
- •Examples of compact boards include Planck (48 keys), Corne (42 keys), and GergoPlex (36 keys).
- •Around 36 keys is suggested as a practical lower bound for normal English typing.
- •Custom firmware layers are used to access missing keys, requiring memorization and muscle memory adjustments.
- •Miryoku is highlighted as a 36-key layout with six layers and home row mods, which can involve timing tuning.