India's VIP culture is out of control

80k VIPs, flashing sirens, and citizens left eating dust

TLDR: The Economist says India’s leaders preach service while enjoying VIP perks and convoys. Commenters seized on “80,000 government-escorted VIPs,” mocking the “chief servant” brand, while a moderator’s “[stub for offtopicness]” and a lone “.” became memes; the crowd demanded fewer escorts and more humility—because everyday people bear the delays.

India’s leaders say they’re humble “public servants,” but commenters saw The Economist’s report and immediately rolled their eyes. When Narendra Modi calls himself “chief servant,” the thread answered with irony: servants don’t travel in siren-lit convoys. The mood? A blend of punchlines and palpable frustration.

The mic-drop stat came from enjoykaz: “80,000 government-escorted VIPs” roaming one country. That number became a meme in minutes—“80,000 reasons your bus is late,” “80,000 flashing beacons of humility,” and, inevitably, “80,000 Chief Servants, 0 common lanes.” Some pushed the security angle, saying top officials need protection; most shot back that protection doesn’t have to look like royalty. The vibe was: if service is the brand, why does it feel like we’re serving them?

Moderation drama added spice. HN’s guardian, dang, parachuted in with “[stub for offtopicness]”, instantly becoming the thread’s inside joke—every tangent got “stubbed.” And DenverR’s single “.” became the minimalist meme: “period, that’s the post.” Between jokes, commenters pitched fixes: make VIPs ride public transport for a week, cap escorts, publish convoy costs. Whether any of it happens, the crowd agreed on one thing: VIP culture looks less like service and more like a parade. The punchlines kept coming, louder than sirens.

Key Points

  • The article examines India’s VIP culture and contrasts it with leaders’ claims of public service.
  • Narendra Modi has consistently said the government exists to serve citizens.
  • In 2014, Modi declared he was the nation’s “chief servant,” not merely prime minister.
  • India’s home minister recently stated the Modi government is synonymous with service, not power.
  • The column frames a disconnect between service-oriented rhetoric and VIP behavior among leaders.

Hottest takes

"80,000 government-escorted VIPs in one country" — enjoykaz
"[stub for offtopicness]" — dang
"." — DenverR
Made with <3 by @siedrix and @shesho from CDMX. Powered by Forge&Hive.