How Costco Won in Japan

Five-hour lines, giant mayo, and a fresh fight with Amazon

TLDR: Costco’s Okinawa opening drew hours-long lines, underscoring how the warehouse giant cracked Japan with big value and fewer stores. Commenters split hard: some say Amazon Fresh beats Costco’s time drain, a local questions wage impact, and others demand [AI] labels—proof the bulk wars now include the comments section

Japan’s latest Costco opening in Okinawa turned into a five-hour parking saga and a three-and-a-half-hour door line — the most polite chaos you’ll ever see. The article credits Costco’s slow-and-steady strategy for winning where Walmart and Carrefour stumbled: fewer stores (37), huge value, and a 1999 head start outside Tokyo. But the comments? Whew.

The loudest split: speed vs. bulk. One camp says Costco is a weekend boss fight; Amazon Fresh is the cheat code. A top critic calls Costco a “negative value” time sink with “dark patterns,” swearing that delivery is faster and fresher. Bulk diehards clap back with the cult classics: giant mayo, cheap rotisserie chickens, and the joy of treasure-hunting deals.

From Japan, a local adds nuance: higher part-time pay is nice, but these warehouses are often out in the sticks — so don’t expect visible wage miracles. Meanwhile, meta-drama blossoms: one reader begs for [AI] tags on AI-written stories, another nitpicks the headline year. And then there’s the meme of the day: “Costco makes me want to be American,” which spirals into jokes about bald eagles in the snack aisle.

Verdict: Costco’s Okinawa hype proves the model works in Japan — but the community’s divided between cart-pushers and couch-clickers, and they brought popcorn

Key Points

  • Costco opened a new warehouse in Okinawa in late 2024, drawing hours-long lines to park and enter.
  • Japan is Costco’s largest market outside North America, with 37 warehouses and an estimated 6 million members.
  • Costco entered Japan in 1999 in Fukuoka Prefecture, succeeding where foreign retailers like Walmart, Tesco, Metro, and Carrefour struggled.
  • Costco’s approach in Japan emphasizes location, merchandising, and store design, adapting its model to local conditions.
  • Historically, Costco grew rapidly after its 1983 founding, merged with Price Club in 1993, expanded to South Korea (1994) and Taiwan (1997), and navigated Asian market challenges with local partners.

Hottest takes

“Costco has become negative value for me compared to Amazon Fresh” — doctorpangloss
“Costco makes me want to be American” — unixhero
“It’d be nice if AI-written articles had an [AI] after the headline” — brian-armstrong
Made with <3 by @siedrix and @shesho from CDMX. Powered by Forge&Hive.