I'm Scared About Biological Computing

Scientists taught human brain cells to play DOOM — and the comments instantly went feral

TLDR: A writer got deeply unsettled by a company using human neurons grown in a lab to play DOOM, raising the nightmare question of whether we’re creating something that might feel trapped. In the comments, people split between ethical alarm, skeptical mockery, and jokes about terrible gaming skills — which only made the debate hotter.

A blog post about human brain cells being trained to play DOOM has sent the community straight into an existential spiral. The writer’s big fear is simple and deeply creepy: if these lab-grown neurons can take in signals, react, learn, and get rewarded, are we accidentally creating something that can experience its tiny digital prison? That question alone was enough to light up the comments with equal parts panic, philosophy, and people calling nonsense.

The loudest split? One camp went full "this is morally terrifying". One commenter compared it to the ethics of how humans already use living things, basically saying this is just the newest ugly chapter in a very old story. Another jumped straight to the darkest ending possible: there will be no ethical line at all as long as money is involved, and humanity will only care once the "ball of neurons" starts outthinking us. Casual! Meanwhile, others were less horror-movie and more eye-roll. A skeptic accused the author of getting spooked by a YouTube video instead of doing the reading, and even roasted the claim that the neuron blob played DOOM "better than I do" by suggesting, maybe brutally, that the author might just be terrible at DOOM.

And then there were the gloriously over-the-top comments treating the whole thing like Greek myth fan fiction: Prometheus, Sisyphus, Zeus — the works. The vibe was part ethics seminar, part Reddit meltdown, part sci-fi cold open. Everyone agrees on one thing, though: if we really did build a tiny wet computer out of human cells, pretending this is just another quirky lab demo is not going to calm anybody down.

Key Points

  • The article compares the author’s familiarity with language-model AI systems to their discomfort with computing systems built from living human neurons.
  • The author references a company video showing lab-grown neurons trained to play DOOM.
  • The piece questions whether neuron-based computing could blur the line between computation and consciousness.
  • The article argues that uncertainty about consciousness becomes more difficult when biological neurons are processing inputs and producing responses.
  • The author says commercial incentives could drive further development of biological computing because of possible advantages in storage, retrieval, and power efficiency.

Hottest takes

"Anyone who believes AI running on silicon could in principle be conscious has to believe that biological computers are conscious, right?" — lukasb
"Maybe the author really really sucks at DOOM" — LeCompteSftware
"There will be no line as long as there is the rush to win the capitalist game" — FrustratedMonky
Made with <3 by @siedrix and @shesho from CDMX. Powered by Forge&Hive.