I Found Ultra-Pure Quantum Crystals in an Abandoned Mine in the Atacama Desert

Science says breakthrough, comments say ancient aliens and time travel in a dusty mine

TLDR: A researcher says he found rare natural crystals in an abandoned Chilean mine that may help future quantum computing research, and in surprisingly large amounts. The community split between impressed curiosity and full meme mode, with jokes about ancient civilizations, time travel, and whether anyone can tell purity from a photo.

A scientist trekked into Chile’s Atacama Desert and came back with the kind of story that sounds made up at a bar: ultra-pure crystals from an abandoned mine that could help unlock future quantum computers. In plain English, these are rare natural rocks with bizarre magnetic behavior that researchers usually spend years trying to grow in labs. The wild part? Dr. Aaron Breidenbach says one boulder may contain more of the good stuff than he made in six years at Stanford. That alone had readers doing a double take.

But the comments instantly turned this from a science story into a full-on internet variety show. One camp was genuinely impressed, with the understated internet classic of "Neat" doing a lot of heavy lifting. Another crowd immediately swerved into sci-fi chaos, joking that weird mineral deposits are exactly the sort of clue an ancient lost civilization would leave behind. As one commenter basically put it: it’s never the Silurians… but what if? Then came the time-travel brigade, asking whether there was a DeLorean hidden nearby, because apparently abandoned mines can no longer just be abandoned mines.

There was also a mini reality-check thread, with readers asking whether you can actually tell crystal purity from photos, which is the closest this discussion got to a serious challenge. And of course, someone dropped a Turbo Encabulator link, because no internet thread about advanced science is complete without at least one joke about everybody pretending to understand what’s going on. The result: part breakthrough, part meme pit, all very online.

Key Points

  • Aaron Breidenbach says he found natural Herbertsmithite crystals in waste tailings at the abandoned San Francisco mine in Chile’s Atacama Desert.
  • The article describes Herbertsmithite and Zn-Barlowite as candidate quantum spin liquid materials with possible future relevance for quantum computing.
  • Breidenbach says he recently published a Nature Physics paper with Young Lee’s lab presenting evidence for a quantum spin liquid state in these crystals.
  • The field discovery was carried out in collaboration with Vicente Carrasola Vega of the University of Chile, who Breidenbach says first spotted the crystals.
  • The article says the material identity was verified by powder X-ray scattering with help from Joseline Tapia and staff at Universidad Católica del Norte, indicating Herbertsmithite mixed with Atacamite.

Hottest takes

"It’s never the Silurians" — rbanffy
"Was there a DeLorean hidden in the mine nearby?" — totetsu
"Can we tell their purity from looking at the photos?" — koolala
Made with <3 by @siedrix and @shesho from CDMX. Powered by Forge&Hive.