June 5, 2026
Gate closed, drama opened
Amazon's New Stargate Series Is Officially Dead
Fans are fuming as Amazon bins Stargate and commenters roast the excuse
TLDR: Amazon has killed its planned new Stargate series, even after giving it the go-ahead, reportedly over fears it would only attract longtime fans. Commenters and franchise insiders are pushing back hard, calling that excuse weak and accusing executives of chasing only mega-hit franchises.
The new Stargate show is officially toast, and the internet’s reaction is a mix of heartbreak, eye-rolling, and full-on "are you kidding me?" energy. Amazon had ordered a fresh series from longtime franchise veteran Martin Gero, with big names from old-school Stargate involved behind the scenes. Then, in a plot twist fans absolutely did not ask for, the company reportedly backed away because executives worried it would only appeal to hardcore followers. And that explanation? The community is not buying it.
One of the sharpest reactions came from producer Joe Mallozzi, who publicly pushed back and said the show was built as a welcoming starting point for new viewers while still respecting longtime fans. That clash — executives saying "too niche", insiders saying "actually, no" — has become the real drama. Even actor Michael Shanks summed up the mood with a brutally dry response on X: "Yep. They did that." Ouch.
In the comments, the vibes swing between sincere mourning and savage sarcasm. One user snarked, "Convincing evidence that it was going to be a good show," mocking the flood of disappointed creator statements. Another took the practical route, arguing Stargate already had a loyal audience, plenty of story options, and didn’t even need superhero-level money to work — but, they sighed, maybe executives only want the next giant smash hit. So yes, the gate is closed again, and the loudest thing teleporting across the fandom right now is pure frustration.
Key Points
- •Amazon has canceled the new *Stargate* series from Martin Gero, despite ordering it in November 2025.
- •The project was reportedly halted because Amazon executives were concerned it would mainly appeal to diehard fans.
- •The series had been in development after Amazon’s 2022 acquisition of MGM Studios and included multiple longtime *Stargate* figures as producers.
- •Joe Mallozzi publicly disputed the claim that the show was narrowly targeted, saying it was designed as a fresh entry point for new viewers while respecting existing canon.
- •Amazon is still described as interested in continuing the *Stargate* franchise through another possible approach.