Is AI ruining our skills? Early results are in – and they're not good

Doctors and coders are panicking as commenters argue AI is making people lazy

TLDR: A new study suggests professionals can get worse at key tasks after leaning on AI, including doctors whose performance dropped when the tool disappeared. Commenters are split between "that’s just what tools do" and "I’ve watched coworkers turn into zombies," with jokes flying the whole way.

The new fear sweeping offices and hospitals is brutally simple: is artificial intelligence making smart people worse at their jobs? Early research says... maybe yes, and the comment section wasted zero seconds turning that into a full-blown culture war. One study found that after doctors started using an AI helper during colonoscopies, they were worse at spotting warning signs when the tool wasn’t there. In plain English: once the training wheels came off, performance dipped. That was enough to send readers straight into panic, denial, and sarcasm.

The loudest reactions split into two camps. Team "this is normal, relax" compared AI to calculators, arguing people always trade old skills for new tools and life goes on. One commenter basically shrugged: humans got worse at mental math too, and nobody’s smashing their calculator in protest. But Team "I have seen the rot with my own eyes" came in hotter, with one person claiming two senior engineers at a giant tech company had "lost literally all of their skills" after leaning too hard on AI-generated code. Ouch. That turned the debate from abstract science to workplace gossip real fast.

And because the internet cannot resist a punchline, the funniest jab came from a commenter flipping the whole headline on management: "Are employees ruining managers’ skills?" In other words, the studies are serious, but the crowd reaction is the real spectacle: part existential dread, part office rant, part meme factory.

Key Points

  • The article says early studies suggest reliance on AI tools can degrade professional skills in medicine and software engineering.
  • A survey of US health-care workers found that 70% of nurses and 77% of physicians were worried about losing skills because of over-reliance on AI systems.
  • In a Poland study of experienced endoscopy physicians, adenoma detection in colonoscopies performed without AI fell from 28.4% before AI introduction to 22.4% after the tool was introduced.
  • The endoscopy findings were published in *The Lancet Gastroenterology and Hepatology* and are presented as evidence that even highly skilled professionals may perform worse without AI after using it.
  • The article also cites a randomized controlled trial by Anthropic involving 52 software engineers, with half prompted to use an AI assistant while completing a basic coding task.

Hottest takes

"lost literally all of their skills" — iLoveOncall
"people got worse at arithmetic after the invention of the calculator" — devolving-dev
"Are employees ruining managers' skills?" — antonvs
Made with <3 by @siedrix and @shesho from CDMX. Powered by Forge&Hive.