European "age verification" "app" forcing everyone to use Android or iOS

EU age-check plan sparks outrage as users say they’re being pushed into Apple or Google’s arms

TLDR: Critics say Europe’s age-check app could make Android and iPhone the only practical way to access some online services. Commenters are split between outrage over losing choice and dark humor about how Apple and Google now seem to hold the keys to the internet.

The idea behind Europe’s new age-check system may sound simple: prove you’re old enough to access certain websites. But the community reaction? Absolute side-eye, panic, and a lot of “wait… seriously?” The biggest outrage is not even about age checks themselves — it’s that people fear the system effectively forces everyone onto Android or iPhone, handing even more power to Apple and Google while shutting out anyone who wants to use something else.

That sparked a deliciously messy comment-section pile-on. One camp was furious on principle, with users saying it’s just plain wrong to need a specific phone platform to use major parts of the internet. Another camp came in with the brutally practical response: “Okay, but what other phones are people actually using?” Cue the ghostly roll call of dead or niche mobile systems — Symbian, WebOS, and assorted "does anyone still have one of those?" jokes. The vibe was basically: this is bad… but also, are there even any realistic alternatives left?

Then the geopolitics arrived and the thread got spicier. One commenter warned that relying on two US tech giants for access to state-backed identity tools means Europe could be left helpless if Apple, Google, or even the US government pulled the plug. Another wondered if some tiny outsider platform should “sue the hell out of the EU.” Beneath the snark was a serious fear: Europe says it wants digital independence, but critics think this plan does the exact opposite — with extra app-store drama on top.

Key Points

  • The article claims the proposed European age-verification system would effectively require users to use Android or iOS.
  • The article criticizes reliance on proprietary mobile attestation tools, especially Google Play Integrity, for securing age-verification apps.
  • It proposes a browser-based challenge-response flow using a national identity provider and signed files as an alternative to app-centric verification.
  • The article cites multiple GitHub issues related to the Italian Wallet / IO app as examples of Play Integrity-related implementation problems.
  • It argues that rooted-device risks could be mitigated through encryption, app signature checks, server-side verification, and short-lived identifiers instead of Play Integrity.

Hottest takes

"not right to be forced to use a specific platform" — roundabout-host
"sue the hell out of the EU" — amelius
"Effectively handing the keys to your state ID to private foreign enterprise" — sschueller
Made with <3 by @siedrix and @shesho from CDMX. Powered by Forge&Hive.