July 15, 2026
Your comments are in another castle
Ask HN: How do you track feedback when you post across multiple places?
Posting everywhere, drowning in replies, and begging the internet for one sane inbox
TLDR: A maker asked whether anyone else struggles to track feedback after posting on several social sites, where replies end up scattered everywhere. The community agreed the problem is real, but argued over whether this needs a new tool or just better habits, with plenty of jokes about drowning in notifications.
A founder showed up on Hacker News with a painfully relatable problem: post your project on X, Reddit, Facebook and everywhere else, and suddenly feedback is scattered like glitter after a party. The pitch was simple — does anyone else hate chasing comments across the whole internet? — but the community reaction quickly turned the question into a mini soap opera about modern online life.
The strongest mood was a mix of "yes, this is real" and "careful, this could become another pointless tool". Some people sympathized hard, saying that getting feedback today feels less like having a conversation and more like hunting breadcrumbs across five apps and twelve notification tabs. Others came in with instant skepticism, basically asking whether this is a genuine problem or just a fancy way to create one more dashboard nobody wants to open. That split gave the thread its drama: one side sees chaos, the other sees clutter disguised as a solution.
And of course, the jokes landed fast. People compared the situation to needing a private investigator for your own comment section, while others joked that if your users want to talk to you, they’ll simply choose the platform where you’re least likely to answer. The vibe was classic internet: a little helpful, a little snarky, and deeply aware that the real product challenge isn’t collecting feedback — it’s surviving the mess of places where people love to leave it.
Key Points
- •The author says they have worked on multiple projects over the last two years.
- •They report repeatedly facing the same issue when trying to get feedback from people.
- •The author posts across multiple platforms, specifically X, Reddit, and Facebook.
- •Responses are described as scattered across different places rather than centralized.
- •The post asks others whether they have the same problem and links to remarkd.app to share experiences.