Do we just want slaves?

AI fans and haters agree on one thing: let the machine do the boring stuff

TLDR: A creator’s provocative question about whether people want AI to be their "slaves" sparked backlash and soul-searching after critics of AI admitted they still use it for tedious work. Commenters split between mocking the comparison and agreeing it exposed an ugly truth about who gets replaced first.

A spicy post from OpenSauce turned into a full-on comment-section cage match after one creator asked the loaded question: "Do we just want slaves?" The writer’s point was simple enough: people say they fear artificial intelligence, but they’re also perfectly happy when it edits their videos, speeds up designs, or handles the annoying chores they never liked doing in the first place. At the event, even some AI critics admitted the tools make life easier, which lit the fuse.

And wow, the community did not stay calm. One camp instantly dragged the title, saying it wildly missed the point of slavery altogether. As one commenter snapped, the problem with slavery is taking away human freedom, not taking work off someone’s plate. Another rolled their eyes so hard you could hear it through the screen: "Is a calculator a slave? Is a car a slave?" That became the thread’s unofficial meme, with people basically arguing that humans have always invented tools to dodge tedious labor.

But others said the post accidentally hit a nerve. They agreed that society loves to romanticize creativity while gleefully automating the jobs it sees as dull, low-status, or beneath notice. The harshest dunk? A commenter saying the author got a tiny flash of class consciousness before admitting they help build the very system they’re worried about. In other words: less a tech debate, more a public morality play with robots, hypocrisy, and plenty of popcorn

Key Points

  • The article reports that AI criticism was widespread at OpenSauce talks and panels.
  • The author says this year's event showed more acceptance that AI can sometimes be useful, compared with earlier blanket opposition.
  • The article cites examples of creators acknowledging AI benefits in video editing, prototyping, and other workflow tasks.
  • A panel example involving VSauce is used to show tension between using AI and limiting children's exposure to computers.
  • The author says they work in AI, are involved in improving it, and are questioning where to draw the line on acceptable automation.

Hottest takes

"Is a calculator a slave? Is a car a slave?" — cognitiveinline
"If the slaves are robots/machines then yes we very much want slaves." — dyauspitr
"Aibro gets a glimpse at class consciousness for half a second" — foxes
Made with <3 by @siedrix and @shesho from CDMX. Powered by Forge&Hive.